- "I suggest we continue to argue!"
- —Erewhon to Ishmael
Erewhon is one of the islanders the Baudelaires meet in The End. She is an old woman who helps orchestrate the mutiny against Ishmael. She reveals that she washed up on The Island after living on another island even farther away.
She taught Miranda Caliban the backstroke, despite Ishmael saying it is not the customary way to swim.